Our team is available now — confidential consultation 24/7 Instant reply from a specialist01026009992
Mental health · The law

Criminal responsibility and mental illness Between illness and accountability

A psychiatric patient's legal responsibility isn't removed automatically by a diagnosis. It's judged case by case based on the capacity to understand and choose at the time of the act, decided by the courts with specialist psychiatric assessment. A patient in acute psychosis differs from someone stable or with a disorder that doesn't affect understanding. This is general information and doesn't replace a lawyer's advice.

Written by Updated: 2 min read
Criminal responsibility and mental illness

01What is assessed?

Element Question
Understanding Did they understand the nature of the act?
Choice Could they control themselves?
State at the time Acute episode or stable?
Cause Illness or voluntary substance use?
Infographic showing the difference between loss and reduction of awareness under Article 62
According to the article

02The usual path

  1. The incidentproceedings begin.
  2. Requesting assessmentby the court or defence.
  3. Psychiatric examinationby specialists.
  4. Reportsubmitted to the court.
  5. Decisionthe court's alone.

Misconceptions

  • «Any psychiatric patient can't be held accountable».
  • «Drugs excuse responsibility».

More accurate

  • Assessment case by case.
  • The court decides.

Read also: kleptomania, psychiatric hospital, psychosis.

؟Frequently asked questions

Is a psychiatric patient legally responsible?

It depends on their state at the time of the act, as the court decides after medical assessment.

Does a diagnosis exempt from punishment?

Not automatically; the standard is loss of understanding or choice at the time.

What about crimes under the influence of drugs?

Voluntary use usually doesn't excuse, and details vary by law and case.

Who assesses the case?

Specialist psychiatrists or committees appointed by the judicial authorities.

Can a patient be committed for treatment instead of punishment?

In some cases authorities may order treatment, according to the law.

Is this legal advice?

No. It's general information; consult a specialist lawyer.

Is a psychiatric patient legally responsible?

It depends on their state at the time of the act, as the court decides after medical assessment.

Does a diagnosis exempt from punishment?

Not automatically; the standard is loss of understanding or choice at the time.

What about crimes under the influence of drugs?

Voluntary use usually doesn't excuse, and details vary by law and case.

Who assesses the case?

Specialist psychiatrists or committees appointed by the judicial authorities.

Can a patient be committed for treatment instead of punishment?

In some cases authorities may order treatment, according to the law.

Is this legal advice?

No. It's general information; consult a specialist lawyer.

Sources and references

  1. Mental health: strengthening our response — World Health Organization
  2. Mental disorders — fact sheet — World Health Organization
  3. Mental health: strengthening our response — World Health Organization
  4. Mental disorders — fact sheet — World Health Organization
Dr. Mahmoud Elsawy
Written byConsultant in psychiatry and addiction treatment

A psychiatrist specialising in addiction and mental illness in adults and adolescents, with a focus on dual diagnosis.

Published: 17 November 2026 Updated: 17 November 2026 Written and medically reviewed

For awareness only — not a substitute for medical advice. Editorial policy · View profile

Call now WhatsApp